What to Say When You Catch Your Friend Stealing

How would you deal with a friend stealing from you? Having someone you once trusted steal take something of yours can leave you feeling betrayed, angry and violated. Getting your belongings back is fairly straight forward, but the breach of trust can make you seriously question your judgement skills and cause an abrupt end to your friendship.

Maybe you’ve caught a friend stealing from others and now your concerned about this person’s character. Should you confront them, and if so how? Read on because we’ve got some tips and tricks for you:

1 | Do You Have Enough Evidence or is It Just a Suspicion?


This is one of the toughest problems to deal with in friendship. Because not only do you run the risk of losing someone you considered a friend, but you also run the risk of having trust issues in the future. Because when someone steals from you they don’t just take something that is yours, they also take away a piece of you that will not be easy to replace.

Deciding on the most appropriate way to confront your friend depends on how much evidence you have against this friend. If you know without a shadow of a doubt that they stole from you, no matter how uncomfortable it is to handle, you do need to confront them.  Tell them:

There is something I need to talk to you about and it is not easy for me to do this, but I have decided to tell you because I want you to know how deeply it hurt me and I never thought I would have this conversation with you because I consider you a good friend.

Then explain what is missing and how you figured out it was them. It will be more difficult to have this conversation if you have a good feeling that they stole from you but not solid proof. In this case, it is better to go step by step and eliminate possibilities as you go. You can start the conversation by talking about the missing item, or money. Keep it factual and don’t mention you suspect them. If you mention you suspect them at this stage they will get defensive and it will lead to an unpleasant argument.

Remember, you want them to not be defensive, but defenseless instead. From the way they react, you might have a clearer picture as to whether or not they had anything to do with it. This may or may not lead you to a definitive answer, but it might scare them and make them think twice before they attempt to steal from you or anyone else in the future.

2 | You Have Evidence but You Are Afraid of Confronting


If you don’t know how to go about having this dreadful conversation, you can pull away and stop communicating with this person. Ignoring their messages and turning down their invites will become a burden for a while, hopefully, they will get the message fast enough and stop bothering you.

If they ask you what’s wrong and why you suddenly stopped talking to them you can find a million excuses from “I am really busy these days” to “I am not feeling good today”.  Most of the time we are afraid of confronting for various reasons. Maybe we have a little doubt and we hate to accuse someone falsely and we don’t feel comfortable enough to live with such guilt forever.

So we save ourselves the embarrassment in case we are wrong. Another reason why confronting is not easy is because we simply don’t have the strength to have this type of conversation. So we simply let it go and try to move on and be more careful with our choices in the future.

Illustrations courtesy of Shutterstock.

This article was originally published on https://www.nevertherightword.com. If this article appears on any other site other than https://www.nevertherightword.com without clear referencing it is a violation of the copyright owned by https://www.nevertherightword.com.

This article may contain affiliate links. That means if you click and buy a product, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Never the Right Word is a participant in the Awin Affiliates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to participating merchants. For more information, please view our Privacy Policy and Earnings Disclosure page.

3 | You Have Evidence and You Do Want to Confront


Honestly, it is the right thing to do no matter how hard and means it looks and feels. There are two things to consider: was this a one-time incident or does your friend have a more serious problem that needs treatment? If this was a one-time incident you will have to decide how you want to proceed. Do you want to stay friends with this person or do you want to let them know that this action has serious consequences? At this point tell them you need to talk to them about something serious.

With calmness, put all the evidence in front of them in a way they won’t be able to find any excuses. Tell them how you became suspicious, how you figured out it was them. Be clear.

Suppose you were invited to their house. And when you went there you had a golden ring in your purse. You went to the bathroom and left your purse in the living room. You did not interact with anyone else that day and you went straight home afterward.

The next morning when you opened your purse the ring was no longer there. Explain all of this calmly to your friend. They will know what you are trying to tell them even though they probably won’t admit it. Tell them how hard it is for you to have this talk with them but it is better to handle it now than never talk about it.

4 | What if They Apologize?


Thank you for being honest with me and admitting. However, I would like you to know that this hurt me a lot and I will need more time to trust you again, I hope you understand, but this is how I feel…
I feel terrible that we had to go through this. I wish this never happened. However, I hope you understand that things can’t be the same anymore. I don’t think I can trust you and I can’t be friends with someone if I can’t trust them.

Depending on the severity of the theft, you will decide if you still want to be friends with this person or not. If you choose to forgive, you should let them know that they have to pay it back to you. If the amount was big, you can arrange a payment plan.

If the amount wasn’t big, you two can decide on a specific date for your friend to reimburse it to you. But they have to know that they can’t get away with it. If you want to accept their apology and give them another chance you should let them know that it will take time for you to trust them again.

You can say: “Thank you for being honest with me and admitting. However, I would like you to know that this hurt me a lot and I will need more time to trust you again, I hope you understand, but this is how I feel”.

If you don’t want to give them another chance tell them that you still expect to be paid back and say: “I feel terrible that we had to go through this. I wish this never happened. However, I hope you understand that things can’t be the same anymore. I don’t think I can trust you and I can’t be friends with someone if I can’t trust them.”

No matter how hard it is to say these things, they need to be said. You will feel horrible and perhaps even guilty. But remind yourself that it is not your fault and this was the best decision. Give yourself time to heal and learn from this experience.

If you're looking to develop your communication skills for professional environments even further, we think you’ll like the following video course from LinkedIn Learning.
Click here for full access to "Holding Yourself Accountable" On LinkedIn Learning
In this course, personal branding expert Dorie Clark helps you adopt the accountability mindset. Dorie outlines specific, practical steps you can take to implement accountability.This course teaches you to amplify the urgency of your mission, understand why it matters, and know how taking responsibility helps you become the kind of person you want to be.

At Never the Right Word, our aim is to give you practical examples of how to handle life’s difficult conversations. If you have an awkward situation that you’d like example templates for, request a topic here.  

If you’re interested in further reading, we’ve also included links to our trusted resources and related posts below. To find out more about NTRW and our recommended tools, you can do that here.

Lastly, if you found this content helpful or want to share your own examples, let us know in the comments. We’d also be delighted if you shared this article and joined us on social media too!

Article by Never the Right Word

Scripts & Templates for Life’s Uncomfortable Conversations. Learn more about NTRW here. NTRW is supported by adverts and affiliate marketing links. For more info, please see our Earnings Disclosure.

This site does not constitute legal, mental, or medical health advice, please consult a competent licensed professional. If you have questions please Contact Us.

Never the Right Word

Never the Right Word

Hi there! I’m Amy, and I’m the person behind Never the Right Word. I’m a designer-by-day who’s fascinated by human psychology; you’ll find me learning about what makes others tick through all types of media and good old-fashioned conversation. Learn more about me here.

In 2019 Never the Right Word was born to fill the gap of ‘how-to’ websites with copy and paste examples showing you EXACTLY what you need to say to steer difficult conversations into positive outcomes.

Recent Articles...

Relevant Books We Recommend...

Crucial Accountability: Tools for Resolving Violated Expectations, Broken Commitments, and Bad Behavior, Second Edition ( Paperback) (Paperback)

In Crucial Accountability: Tools for Resolving Violated Expectations, Broken Commitments, and Bad Behavior by Kerry Patterson, tools for improving professional and personal relationships permanently are explored. Crucial Accountability provides a simple step by step approach for effectively discussing issues with others when they disappoint. It starts by helping us challenge the belief that we simply cannot speak up to certain people and then offers practical tools to use during the confrontation. The goal for Crucial Accountability is to open the lines of communication making our relationships less stressful, and far more rewarding in return. Get your copy of Crucial Accountability by CLICKING HERE.

Get the Truth: Former CIA Officers Teach You How to Persuade Anyone to Tell All (Paperback)

Tired of having the wool pulled over your eyes? Get the Truth: Former CIA Officers Teach You How to Persuade Anyone to Tell All is a step-by-step guide that empowers readers to extract the truth from others. As former CIA agents and bestselling authors of Spy the Lie, Philip Houston, Mike Floyd, and Susan Carnicero are among the world's best at detecting deceptive behavior and eliciting the truth from even the most skilled liars. The authors provide an easy and effective way of getting absolutely anybody to give an honest answer. Whilst you won't become an instant expert overnight, you can easily learn the skills the experts use to steer the outcome of conversations. CLICK HERE to get your copy of Get the Truth.

Everybody Lies (Paperback)

Eye-opening, amusing, and somewhat concerning Everybody Lies by Seth Stephens-Davidowitz has us extremely inquisitive over what people are really thinking and Googling. In this groundbreaking work, Stephens-Davidowitz, a Harvard-trained economist, former Google data scientist, and New York Times writer, argues that much of what we thought about people isn't necessarily the full picture. Packed with statistics provided by a wealth of endless search history data and interesting queries, if you're curious about what humans are really like- you're likely to thoroughly enjoy this book. Get your copy of Everybody Lies by CLICKING HERE.

What Every BODY is Saying

In What Every Body Is Saying: An Ex-FBI Agent's Guide to Speed-reading People we are shown how we can use our subconscious statements to use to our greatest advantage and also gain clues to what others are 'saying' nonverbally. Author Joe Navarro, a former FBI counterintelligence officer and a recognized expert on nonverbal behavior, teaches readers many skills such as how to "speed-read" people; correctly analyze moods and intentions, and decode and detect deceptive behaviors. Readers are also shown how their body language can influence what their employers, friends, and family, and even strangers think of you. CLICK HERE to get your copy by clicking here.

Pin Never the Right Word on Pinterest!

Check Out Our Recommended Resources.

Looking to become a digital publisher like us? We highly recommend these tried-and-tested tools:

We Recommend Elegant Themes

The Elegant Themes membership gives you complete access to 87 amazing themes and 3 awesome plugins, including Divi, the ultimate WordPress Theme and Visual Page builder. Elegant Themes have been building the world's most popular WordPress themes for the past 10 years, and rest assured their products will always be improved and maintained.

Divi WordPress Theme

Build Anything With Divi Theme

One of the most popular WordPress themes in the world. Building layouts is easy and fast, making it ideal to create mockups and wireframes, prototyping a design, and creating the website itself. Build from the frontend or backend. The builder is intuitive. It's easy to learn and can be used by non-developers to create amazing websites.

Divi Cake is a community driven marketplace for Divi Child Themes, Builder Layouts, and Plugins - Shop Now!

Customize With Divi Cake Plugins

Divi Cake’s main goal is to help the members of the Divi community find the perfect premium Divi themes, layouts, and plugins created by leading Divi developers and designers. Shop hundreds of premium Divi products like Divi child themes, Divi layouts, and Divi plugins on Divi Cake, the community-driven Divi Marketplace. Find out more about Divi Cake here.

We ❤️Shutterstock Media

We get our images from the OG in stock assets. Boost your business with the right images. They're royalty-free and ready to use. Footage & Music Libraries. 4k Images Added per Hour. No Daily Download Limit. Speedy Search & Discovery. With flexible plans and countless amounts of premium content uploaded weekly, we had to mention Shutterstock.

Skill-Up With LinkedIn Learning

When you want to enhance your professional skills with expert-led, online video tutorials, the only place to go is LinkedIn Learning (Lynda). With a subscription you get 24/7, unlimited access to over 13,000 business, design & tech online courses and with a free month. We like them because we get expert-led courses that we can access anytime, anywhere. What's not to love?

Web Hosting

Reliable Hosting With SiteGround

SiteGround boasts a whole list of fantastic features at amazingly affordable prices. Along with multiple growth options, free site transfers and domains, built-in Content Delivery Network integrations, WordPress support, AND human support we wouldn't go to anyone else. They're basically faster, safer, and more supportive- you can check them out here.

We Trust Grammarly Premium

Even seasoned writers need a helping hand at times, that’s why we trust Grammarly Premium. As the World's Most Accurate Online Grammar Checker, Grammarly Premium goes beyond grammar to help you ensure that everything you write is clear, engaging, and professional. Try Grammarly Premium’s AI-powered assistant here.

Find Graphics With Creative Market

Creative Market is the world’s marketplace for design. Bring your creative projects to life with ready-to-use design assets from independent creators around the world. We love the unique finds, social media templates, vectors you name it they have it. I also doesn't hurt that our founder has a little store on there...

Powered by Creative Market

Powered by Creative Market

Contact Us

Contact Form

Write to:
Never the Right Word
Building 19475
PO Box 6945
United Kingdom

Follow NTRW

Support NTRW

Donating to Never the Right Word will
help us produce more free content. Thank you!

Stay in the Loop

Pin It on Pinterest